FARM RULEBOOK — RESEARCH BINDER Wisconsin Activities: U-pick and orchards Generated: 2026-11-20T12:50:58.096266+00:00 Scoped research only. An absent or unavailable finding is not a no-law result. AI support, source access and permission for a property are separate questions. This download contains current server research. Private tab notes are included only by printing the research desk. Definitions and liability research unavailable Published AI-prepared research. Verification method: https://farmrulebook.com/how-we-verify/#accuracy. This is a research aid, not permission to operate. Scope: Prepared research for Wisconsin; the substantive scope is withheld with this finding. Independent AI passage support: Passage support checked by a second AI; checked 2026-11-04T23:06:54.988383+00:00 Selected activities: U-pick and orchards Finding unavailable; source resolution or required reassessment pending. Official source to continue research: Wisconsin current Chapter 895 including agricultural tourism 895.524 Wisconsin Legislature https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/statutes/statutes/895.pdf Document changed; dependent finding withheld Retained copy retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:34:22.546800+00:00 Unresolved: This prepared finding is withheld because current exact-version source status is unresolved, changed, or corrected. Obtain the current official text before using it. Suggested research steps: Ask the responsible authority for the current provision and its application to your proposed activity. Definitions and liability research unavailable Published AI-prepared research. Verification method: https://farmrulebook.com/how-we-verify/#accuracy. This is a research aid, not permission to operate. Scope: Prepared research for Wisconsin; the substantive scope is withheld with this finding. Independent AI passage support: Support gap flagged by a second AI; checked 2026-11-04T23:06:54.988383+00:00 Selected activities: U-pick and orchards Finding unavailable; source resolution or required reassessment pending. Official source to continue research: Wisconsin current Chapter 895 including agricultural tourism 895.524 Wisconsin Legislature https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/statutes/statutes/895.pdf Document changed; dependent finding withheld Retained copy retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:34:22.546800+00:00 Unresolved: The independent AI passage-support check is unresolved. The explanation is withheld; this does not determine what the law requires. Suggested research steps: Ask the responsible authority for the current provision and its application to your proposed activity. Definitions and liability research unavailable Published AI-prepared research. Verification method: https://farmrulebook.com/how-we-verify/#accuracy. This is a research aid, not permission to operate. Scope: Prepared research for Wisconsin; the substantive scope is withheld with this finding. Independent AI passage support: Passage support checked by a second AI; checked 2026-11-04T23:06:54.988383+00:00 Selected activities: U-pick and orchards Finding unavailable; source resolution or required reassessment pending. Official source to continue research: Wisconsin current Chapter 895 including agricultural tourism 895.524 Wisconsin Legislature https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/statutes/statutes/895.pdf Document changed; dependent finding withheld Retained copy retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:34:22.546800+00:00 Unresolved: This prepared finding is withheld because current exact-version source status is unresolved, changed, or corrected. Obtain the current official text before using it. Suggested research steps: Ask the responsible authority for the current provision and its application to your proposed activity. Wisconsin’s home-baking position does not extend to all shelf-stable homemade foods Published AI-prepared research. Verification method: https://farmrulebook.com/how-we-verify/#accuracy. This is a research aid, not permission to operate. Scope: DATCP current home-baking guidance and 2024 WI App 69 ¶¶1–5, 39. Independent AI passage support: Passage support checked by a second AI; checked 2026-11-04T23:06:54.988383+00:00 Selected activities: U-pick and orchards DATCP describes the continuing home-baker route for not-potentially-hazardous baked goods sold directly to consumers, with separate licensing for commercial kitchens or wholesale. Its examples concern dry-heat baking in a closed chamber; dehydration alone is not baking. The Court of Appeals’ 2024 opinion reversed the broader injunction for unbaked nonhazardous foods and ordered judgment for DATCP; it distinguishes the earlier unappealed baked-food case. Conditions: The ready-for-sale product must be not potentially hazardous, not merely contain ingredients that started shelf-stable. The agency webpage prints an inconsistent Supreme Court date preceding the appellate decision. The current docket request failed, so this packet does not endorse that date or invent a verified later procedural history. The court’s holding about the broader unbaked-food challenge is not a new general authorization for every baked product; confirm current case status and agency application. Exceptions and limits: No general all-nonhazardous-food exemption, commercial-kitchen exemption, wholesale permission or safety certification follows. https://datcp.wi.gov/Pages/Licenses_Permits/HomeBakers.aspx Wisconsin Department of Agriculture Trade and Consumer Protection DATCP current home-baking limits and product/direct-sales conditions Retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:33:30.697125+00:00 Retained SHA-256: dbcfe7c02c4f1b63db563e4d6a90808abde602926ca1dfb444dbe38d6e4a74e6 Supporting passage: The court's orders apply only to people producing baked goods in their homes. All commercial kitchen baking businesses must follow the Wisconsin Administrative Code requirements of ATCP 70 (Wholesale Food Manufacturing), or ATCP 75 (Retail Food Establishments) and its Appendix (Wisconsin Food Code). Commercial kitchens must ensure that all food businesses using their facilities are appropriately licensed. Baked Goods The court's orders apply only to "baked goods." Baked goods are generally exposed to dry heat, transferred via air, at a temperature above 140°F, to a food in a closed chamber such as an oven. Some items considered baked goods are made in a waffle maker or Dutch oven. Items dried in a dehydrator are not considered baked goods. The temperature minimum of 140°F exceeds the “danger zone" in which pathogenic microorganisms might grow.​ Not Potentially Hazardous Food The court’s order only applies to baked goods that are “not potentially hazardous food,” as defined in Wis. Stat. §§ 97.29(1)(dm) and 97.30(1)(bm). An item might or might not be potentially hazardous before it is baked, but the finished, ready-for-sale product must not be potentially hazardous. Any business producing potentially hazardous baked goods must be licensed. Direct Sales to Consumers The court's order only applies if the home baker only sells their items that are not potentially hazardous directly to consumers. A business that is wholesaling baked goods must be licensed. https://www.wicourts.gov/ca/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=878326 Wisconsin Court of Appeals 2024 WI App 69 ¶¶1–5, scoped holding and earlier case distinction Retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:45:03.025593+00:00 Retained SHA-256: 70e2d4c0c0a522df05c6658a4896f66ced735f0625f1392e5f012a00831a5cde Supporting passage: J. The Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection and Randy Romanski (collectively DATCP) appeal from an order of the circuit court finding the retail food establishment laws found in WIS. STAT. § 97.30 (2021-22),1 and WIS. ADMIN. CODE ch. ATCP 75, along with its corresponding appendix, unconstitutional as a violation of equal protection and due process and enjoining DATCP from enforcing the licensing and other requirements found in those laws against sellers of unbaked, “not potentially hazardous,” homemade foods. ¶2 On appeal, DATCP argues that the retail food establishment laws do not violate equal protection or due process and are, therefore, constitutional. In the alternative, DATCP further argues that the circuit court’s injunction should be invalidated due to its vagueness. ¶3 For the reasons set forth below, we conclude that the retail food establishment laws do not violate equal protection or due process and are, therefore, constitutional. Consequently, we reverse the circuit court’s order finding the retail food establishment laws unconstitutional and enjoining DATCP from enforcing those laws against sellers of unbaked, not potentially hazardous, homemade foods. We further remand with directions to enter judgment in favor of DATCP and dismiss the complaint. BACKGROUND ¶4 Wisconsin generally requires that anyone looking to prepare and sell food directly to consumers for a profit obtain a license and follow certain 1 All references to the Wisconsin Statutes are to the 2021-22 version unless otherwise noted. 2 No. 2023AP367 requirements as a “retail food establishment.” See WIS. STAT. § 97.30(1)(c), (2)(a); see also WIS. ADMIN. CODE ch. ATCP 75, ch. ATCP 75 app. (“Wisconsin Food Code”). Among the several requirements for obtaining and maintaining a license and operating a retail food establishment are inspection requirements, food storage and handling requirements, facility requirements, and licensing fees. See, e.g., § 97.30(2)(a), (3); WIS. ADMIN. CODE §§ ATCP 75.06, 75.067. There are also limited exemptions to the retail food establishment laws, including for nonprofit organizations hosting a limited number of events in a calendar year and for producers of specific types of food, such as popcorn, maple syrup, honey, sorghum syrup, and cider. See § 97.30(2)(b)1.; WIS. ADMIN. CODE § ATCP 75.063(5)-(7). DATCP is charged with conducting regular inspections of retail food establishments and ensuring compliance with the retail food establishment laws. Sec. 93.07(24); WIS. ADMIN. CODE § ATCP 75.10. ¶5 In Lafayette County Circuit Court Case No. 2016CV6, Lisa Kivirist, Kriss Marion, and Dela Ends (collectively Kivirist) challenged these retail food establishment laws as applied to Kivirist and similarly situated individuals of baked, 3 No. 2023AP367 not potentially hazardous,2 homemade foods, such as cookies, cakes, and muffins, as a violation of the right to equal protection and due process.3 At a hearing held on May 31, 2017, the circuit court in that case agreed and enjoined DATCP from enforcing the retail food establishment laws against sellers of baked, not potentially hazardous, homemade foods. DATCP did not appeal the circuit court’s decision in Case No. 2016CV6, and in February 2021, Kivirist moved to find DATCP in contempt for violating the injunction.4 The circuit court denied the motion and clarified that its previous order applied to homemade, shelf-stable foods that have been baked in an oven. The retail food establishment laws define “potentially hazardous” food as “a food that requires temperature control” because it is capable of supporting growth of certain foodborne illnesses. WIS. STAT. § 97.30(1)(bm). Generally speaking, potentially hazardous foods require refrigeration. However, its counterpart, i.e., “not potentially hazardous,” is not itself a term defined in the retail food establishment laws. However, as a result of Case No. 2016CV6, WCFA has adopted the term “not potentially hazardous,” and generally uses it interchangeably with the term “shelf-stable” foods, i.e., foods that do not require refrigeration. We emphasize, however, that just because a food does not meet the statutory definition of potentially hazardous does not mean it is free from safety concerns. In other words, a food is not automatically considered safe if it does not qualify as a “potentially hazardous” food. As DATCP’s manager of the Retail Food and Recreational Program Section, James Kaplanek, explained in a report prepared for this case, while there may be fewer food safety concerns presented by foods that are not considered potentially hazardous, there are nevertheless still food safety concerns, such as those related to food allergens and improper handling and labeling. Thus, we do not consider “not potentially hazardous” or “shelf-stable” to be synonymous with “safe.” 2 3 The Honorable Duane M. Jorgenson presided over Case No. 2016CV6 involving the challenge to the retail food establishment laws as it related to baked, not potentially hazardous, homemade foods. Information related to the motion for contempt has been taken from Wisconsin’s CCAP (Consolidated Court Automation Programs). CCAP is an online website that contains information entered by court staff, and this court may take judicial notice of information on CCAP. See Kirk v. Credit Acceptance Corp., 2013 WI App 32, ¶5 n.1, 346 Wis. 2d 635, 829 N.W.2d 522. 4 4 No. 2023AP367 https://www.wicourts.gov/ca/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=878326 Wisconsin Court of Appeals 2024 WI App 69 ¶39 disposition Retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:45:03.025593+00:00 Retained SHA-256: 70e2d4c0c0a522df05c6658a4896f66ced735f0625f1392e5f012a00831a5cde Supporting passage: ¶39 In sum, we conclude that the retail food establishment laws found in WIS. STAT. § 97.30, WIS. ADMIN. CODE § ATCP 75, and Wisconsin’s Food Code found in the corresponding appendix do not violate equal protection or due process. As a result, we reverse the circuit court’s order granting summary judgment in favor of WCFA and enjoining DATCP from enforcing these laws against WCFA and similarly situated individuals. We further remand this matter with directions to enter judgment in favor of DATCP and dismissing WCFA’s complaint. Automated analysis: 2026-11-02T23:47:07.928608+00:00 Automated source comparison: 2026-11-20T03:21:41.495091+00:00 Unresolved: Actual product/baking process, direct sales, current procedural status and other operating requirements remain unresolved. Suggested research steps: Bring the actual baking method, finished product and sales channel to DATCP’s licensing specialist; use the current home-baking guidance and primary appellate opinion, and verify the docket before relying on disputed chronology. Wisconsin’s home-canned guidance separates required labels/signs from suggested batch records Published AI-prepared research. Verification method: https://farmrulebook.com/how-we-verify/#accuracy. This is a research aid, not permission to operate. Scope: DATCP Home-Canned Foods labeling, records and safety guidance. Independent AI passage support: Passage support checked by a second AI; checked 2026-11-04T23:06:54.988383+00:00 Selected activities: U-pick and orchards The agency requires the full homemade/not-state-inspected point-of-sale sign and a product label identifying the canner/address, canning date, complete private-home/no-state-license-or-inspection statement and descending ingredients with major allergen names including sesame. It separately suggests recipe/process, quantities, canning/sale dates/places, receipts and pH records for each batch. Conditions: Use the exact sign and label statements in the cited guidance; one does not replace the other. Batch documentation is described as suggested in this agency source; do not present the recommendation alone as a newly established mandatory record-retention law. Food processors remain liable for what they sell even if exempt from licensing. Exceptions and limits: A complete label does not make a product or sales channel eligible. https://datcp.wi.gov/pages/programs_services/fshomecannedfoods.aspx Wisconsin Department of Agriculture Trade and Consumer Protection DATCP Home-Canned Foods, required signs/labels versus suggested records Retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:33:30.374342+00:00 Retained SHA-256: c91cbb9f64e43c61e1446d6deb13b0f1543c74df0dcfee6e5400938ffd599e1f Supporting passage: Sign at the point of sale, stating the following “These canned goods are homemade and not subject to state inspection." Product labels must include: Name and address of the person who did the canning Date of canning Statement: “This product was made in a private home not subject to state licensing or inspection." All ingredients in descending order of prominence, including the common name for any ingredient that originates from milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans or sesame as these are ingredients that can cause severe allergic reactions in some people, who must be able to recognize when they are present. What records do I need to maintain? It is suggested to maintain the following records of every batch of products made for sale as applicable: Recipe, including procedures and ingredients Amount canned and sold Canning date Sale dates and locations Gross sales receipts Results of any pH test Content_Area2 Automated analysis: 2026-11-02T23:47:07.856876+00:00 Automated source comparison: 2026-11-20T03:21:41.495091+00:00 Unresolved: Actual labels/sign, recipe/allergens, pH and suggested production/sales records remain unchecked. Suggested research steps: Draft the complete sign and labels, and keep the suggested batch/sales records to support actual safety and the per-person annual sales condition; confirm applicability with DATCP. Wisconsin’s home-canned route has a $5,000 per-person annual cap and narrow sales venues Published AI-prepared research. Verification method: https://farmrulebook.com/how-we-verify/#accuracy. This is a research aid, not permission to operate. Scope: DATCP current Home-Canned Foods guidance, a specifically limited agency explanation. Independent AI passage support: Passage support checked by a second AI; checked 2026-11-04T23:06:54.988383+00:00 Selected activities: U-pick and orchards The agency describes home-canned naturally acidic/acidified fruits and vegetables with pH at most 4.6, such as qualifying pickles, salsa, sauerkraut and fruit preserves. Sales may be only producer-direct retail at Wisconsin community/social events, flea markets or farmers markets, at no more than $5,000 per year per person. The agency excludes home sales, wholesale, consignment, internet/out-of-state sales and selling these exempt products alongside licensed foods. Conditions: Identify the actual recipe and sale venue; the $5,000 is not a general cottage-food cap covering every home-baked or licensed food business. Meat/fish/pickled eggs/lemon curd/pesto/dressings are outside the listed route regardless of pH; higher-pH processed produce requires licensing. The agency recommends testing finished acidified products; the source does not make every suggested record or test method a new universal statutory duty. Exceptions and limits: No general home restaurant, canned-meat, online-shipping or full-food-business exemption is established. https://datcp.wi.gov/pages/programs_services/fshomecannedfoods.aspx Wisconsin Department of Agriculture Trade and Consumer Protection DATCP Home-Canned Foods, product/pH, cap and permitted/prohibited sales Retrieved: 2026-11-02T23:33:30.374342+00:00 Retained SHA-256: c91cbb9f64e43c61e1446d6deb13b0f1543c74df0dcfee6e5400938ffd599e1f Supporting passage: Home-canned fruits and vegetables that are naturally acidic or have been acidified by pickling or fermenting. Products must have a pH of 4.6 or lower. Examples of allowable home-canned foods include: pickled fruits and vegetables (not refrigerator pickles), salsas and chutneys, sauerkraut and kimchi, fruit based jams and jellies, cherries/peaches/applesauce and other fruits. For acidified products it is recommended to test the pH of the finished product. Refer to Measuring pH of Foods in the Resources section on the right. What products require a license to sell? Processed fruits or vegetables with a pH higher than 4.6. Other processed products regardless of pH level: fish, meat, pickled eggs, lemon curd, pesto, or dressings. What sales are permitted? No more than $5,000 per year per person. Only retail sales (direct from producer to consumer) are allowed. Sales can only be conducted at community or social events, flea markets or farmers markets in Wisconsin. What sales are not permitted? The following sales are not permitted: out of your home, wholesale (to be sold later by someone else), on consignment, via the internet or out of state, exempt foods (pickle bill products) sold along with licensed foods. Automated analysis: 2026-11-02T23:47:07.856371+00:00 Automated source comparison: 2026-11-20T03:21:41.495091+00:00 Unresolved: Actual recipe/process, pH, person’s annual sales, venue and governing statutory details remain unresolved. Suggested research steps: Prepare the recipe/process, annual per-person sales and proposed event/market for DATCP’s licensing specialist; verify the narrow exemption and use the appropriate license for excluded products/channels. LOCAL RESEARCH TO COMPLETE Identify the property municipality and county; ask which authority has jurisdiction. Obtain the current ordinance section, application, fee schedule and inspection/meeting dates. Record the exact question, response, office, date, limits and next action in the research desk. A private response does not establish a generally applicable agency determination. No referral, payment, permit submission or agency message is made by this export.